A harrowing case that deeply impacted Brooklyn nearly a decade ago has resurfaced as Daniel St. Hubert, the man convicted of the brutal 2014 elevator attack, has died while serving his sentence. The attack claimed the life of six-year-old Prince Joshua “PJ” Avitto and left seven-year-old Mikayla Capers seriously injured. St. Hubert passed away at Green Haven Correctional Facility, where he was serving a 46-year prison sentence for his crimes.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3205f/3205f43d20236c20b297ab599eed15d6092cd2b9" alt="The 2014 Brooklyn Elevator Attack: Convicted Killer Passes Away"
The Tragic Incident
On a fateful day in 2014, Prince Joshua Avitto and Mikayla Capers were attacked while entering an elevator in their East New York housing complex. St. Hubert stabbed both children in a sudden and unprovoked act of violence. PJ succumbed to his injuries, leaving his family and the community in shock and mourning. Mikayla, despite sustaining severe injuries, survived and has since gone on to thrive, now attending college.
Community Reaction to St. Hubert’s Death
The news of St. Hubert’s death has elicited mixed emotions among those affected by his actions. For PJ’s godmother and members of the community, the announcement reopened wounds that, even after nearly a decade, remain raw. While some expressed relief that St. Hubert could no longer harm others, the pain of losing a beloved child and the trauma of that day remain deeply ingrained.
PJ’s godmother reflected on the enduring impact of his loss, stating, “Dead or alive doesn’t make a difference. It doesn’t bring him back.” The grief that followed the attack not only affected PJ’s immediate family but also reverberated throughout the neighborhood.
Remembering Prince Joshua Avitto
Known for his vibrant personality and infectious energy, PJ Avitto left an indelible mark on those who knew him. His memory continues to live on, particularly through a community center established in his honor. This space serves as a symbol of resilience and hope, aiming to inspire and uplift the East New York community that was so deeply affected by his loss.
Mikayla Capers: A Story of Resilience
Mikayla Capers, the other victim of the elevator attack, has shown remarkable strength and determination in the years since the tragedy. Despite the physical and emotional scars, Mikayla has thrived, now pursuing higher education and building a future for herself. Her survival and growth are testaments to her resilience and the support she has received from her family and the community.
A Case That Shook Brooklyn
The 2014 stabbing was a defining moment for Brooklyn, prompting widespread outrage and grief. It highlighted vulnerabilities in community safety and the devastating consequences of unchecked violence. St. Hubert’s actions led to his conviction and a lengthy prison sentence, providing some measure of justice for the victims and their families. However, the lasting impact of the crime serves as a reminder of the profound cost of such senseless acts.
Cause of Death Undisclosed
While St. Hubert’s death marks the end of his incarceration, details surrounding the cause of his passing remain undisclosed. This development brings closure to a chapter of pain for many, though the memories of his actions linger in the hearts and minds of those affected.
Moving Forward
The legacy of PJ Avitto continues to shape the East New York community. Through the center established in his name, his memory inspires acts of kindness, resilience, and community solidarity. For those who survived the ordeal, like Mikayla Capers, the focus remains on healing and building a life of purpose and strength.
While Daniel St. Hubert’s death may close one chapter of this tragic story, the lives he affected and the lessons learned from this tragedy endure. The community remains committed to honoring PJ’s legacy and supporting one another as they navigate the lasting effects of that fateful day.